Humboldt County’s population numbers less than 150,000 people. Naturally, there aren’t a ton of stores. However, the stores that do exist have a certain rural appeal unattainable in larger cities. As I mentioned in my brief note on bookstores, bookstores in particular serve an important purpose in small towns.
With that in mind, here are the four main bookstores in Arcata and Eureka, each with their own unique brands:
Tin Can Mailman-
1000 H St, Arcata, CA. The Tin Can Mailman has served Arcata for over 40 years. The store houses an eclectic collection of used books of all types, including textbooks for students. They also have a trade-in program for store credit or cash. Come here if you’re looking to save money, or find lesser-known titles from better-known authors. Website here.
Northtown Books-
957 H St, Arcata, CA. Just across from the Tin Can Mailman in Arcata, Northtown Books can satisfy all of your new-book needs. Around since 1965, Northtown Books packs a punch in its small space. While the store might not have everything, if Northtown Books’ curated collection doesn’t contain what you’re looking for, maybe you don’t need it anyway. Website here.
The Booklegger-
402 Second St, Eureka, CA. The Booklegger brings a cozy, dungeon-like aesthetic into its space in Old Town Eureka. The Booklegger’s name suits it well, as the store offers used and rare books that you might not find elsewhere. If you’re looking for an older, used title, try the Booklegger. (No website.)
Eureka Books:-
426 Second St, Eureka, CA. Eureka Books offers an historic experience with your bookstore-browsing. Located in a Victorian store built in 1879, Eureka Books carries new, used, and rare vintage books. Of the four listed stores, Eureka Books carries the broadest collection, with two open stories. Come here if you want to find pretty much anything… Or if you want to check out the fortune-telling Zoltar machine out front! Website here.
Hopefully, this gives you some idea of what to expect from these stores. Each has its own offerings and its own unique tastes. If you can, check them all out!



